Which AI is best for a small business? Test it on your team's work
Guy PavlovPublished
- You're choosing an AI plan for your team
- Pay for the assistant that does your team's most repeated task best. Try two on that task for a month, then check how the better one reaches your apps and what it costs.
- Your team uses Google Workspace
- Include Gemini in the trial. You already pay for it, and from the Business Standard edition it works inside Google Docs, Sheets and Drive.
- Your team uses Outlook, Word and Excel
- Try Copilot Business against ChatGPT Business or Claude Team, which also work inside Word and Excel.
- You want a plan that doesn't need Google Workspace or Microsoft 365
- Compare ChatGPT Business and Claude Team on the same task. Each costs US$25 a person a month, or US$20 paid yearly, for two people or more.
- You want the highest-scoring model
- Claude Fable 5.2 scores highest on the Artificial Analysis index, and Claude Team offers it on Premium seats, which cost more and allow more use. Google's new Gemini 4 Carbon is the second-highest model, at 60.
I checked each plan on its vendor's own pages, and each score on Artificial Analysis, on 15 November 2026.
By the time you ask which AI to pay for, a few people on your team are probably using one. Your office manager rewrites job ads in ChatGPT, and an estimator asks Claude to check the wording of a quote, each paying for it themselves. That work gets done, but they keep it in personal accounts, where you can't set rules for it or get it back when someone leaves.
To move that work onto a business plan, pick the task your team repeats most each week, and try two assistants on it for a month with the people who do it now. Pay for the one that does the task best, once you've checked how it reaches the apps your team uses and what it costs per person.
Match the assistant to the work your team does
Test each assistant on work your team finished last week or last month, so the person who did it can check the assistant's version against their own. Use the same task and the same people for both assistants, and compare the results.
Writing and email
Your sent folder already holds the replies to compare against, so email is the quickest work to test. Take five replies from last week, and have the people who wrote them draft each one again with the assistant. Time how long each draft takes to fix, and count the names, dates and prices the assistant gets wrong.
Before the trial starts, check where each assistant's drafts end up. Claude Team can read Gmail but can't create or send emails (opens in a new tab), so people on Gmail paste its drafts in themselves. ChatGPT Business can save its drafts in Outlook (opens in a new tab) once your admin turns that on. Your admin is whoever on your team manages the plan's settings.
Spreadsheets and finance
Pick a report someone on your team builds by hand each month, such as the sales summary or the cash flow sheet, so you have last month's version to check against. Give the assistant a copy of the figures behind last month's report, not the live file. Then ask the person who built the report to check every total against their own, and compare the time they spend with last month's.
If those figures sit in Google Sheets and you're on the Business Starter edition, Gemini can't work inside the sheet, so you'll need the Business Standard edition (opens in a new tab) to test it there.
Finding old files
If people on your team often hunt through folders for an old proposal or a contract clause, test how the assistant finds files. Ask it three questions your team answered from old files last month, and compare each answer with the file it came from.
Before you give any assistant your shared files, check who can open each folder, because anyone who can open a folder can find its files by asking. In Google Drive, a file's owner can stop people downloading or copying it (opens in a new tab), and Gemini then leaves that file out of its answers. If your files are split between Google Drive and Microsoft's SharePoint or OneDrive, Gemini reaches only the Google side.
Customer replies
When your team answers customers, they handle names, orders and account details. Before anyone starts, sort those details into the three groups in my AI use policy template, so everyone knows which ones may go into the assistant.
Then have the assistant draft replies to ten customer questions from last month, and ask the person who answered them to count the drafts they'd send without changes. A person reads every reply before it reaches the customer, during the trial and after.
How good each assistant is
Scores from the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index (opens in a new tab) can help you pick which two assistants to try. The index averages nine exams in four groups that count equally (opens in a new tab). One group is knowledge work, the closest to what your team does, and the others are coding, science and general knowledge. Most of the models the four plans offer score between 55 and 59, so use the scores to make a shortlist and let your team's trial decide.
| Model | Score | Where to get it |
|---|---|---|
| Claude Fable 5.2 | 65 | Claude Team, on Premium seats |
| Gemini 4 Carbon | 60 | The Gemini app, as Google adds it to Google AI Ultra, a separate subscription from Google Workspace |
| Claude Opus 5.5 | 59 | Claude Team |
| GPT-6 Astra | 57 | ChatGPT Business |
| Claude Sonnet 5.5 | 55 | Claude Team, and Copilot Business once your admin allows Anthropic's models |
| GPT-6.1 Sol | 55 | ChatGPT Business and Copilot Business |
| Gemini 4 Hydrogen | 54 | The Gemini app on every edition, and Gemini in Google Sheets from the Business Standard edition |
Each score shows the model at its most careful, when it takes longest over an answer. When GPT-6.1 Sol answers faster, its score drops from 55 to 46. In Excel and PowerPoint, Copilot Business picks the model for you, so choose one from the model menu if you want a particular model from the table.
Gemini 4 Carbon (opens in a new tab), released on 10 November, puts Google at the front of the index with Anthropic, and Gemini 4 Hydrogen (opens in a new tab) followed two days later. Before you decide on Gemini, open the model menu in the Gemini app on your team's own account to see which models your edition gives you.
Someone who'll use the assistant all day needs higher limits on the strongest model. On ChatGPT Business (opens in a new tab) and Claude Team (opens in a new tab), you can buy that person a Premium seat, which allows more use than a Standard seat. You pay US$125 a month for it, or US$100 paid yearly. On Gemini, people on the Business Standard and Business Plus editions can choose Pro in the model menu for up to 25 requests every four hours (opens in a new tab). People on Business Starter can use it too, but their limit isn't published and can change often.
Inside your apps, or connected to them
Once you've picked your two assistants, look at how each one reaches the apps your team works in. In the table, "Inside" means the assistant works in a panel beside the email or file you have open. Otherwise it connects to the app from its own window, and the table says whether it can only read what's in the app or also take action in it, such as sending an email or creating a file. Your admin controls which of these panels and connections people can use. They also choose, for each connection, whether the assistant may take action. On ChatGPT Business, the assistant can't take action in Google's or Microsoft's apps until your admin turns that on (opens in a new tab).
| App or feature | ChatGPT Business | Claude Team | Gemini | Copilot Business |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gmail | Connected, reads and takes action | Connected, reads only | Inside, on every edition | Connected, reads |
| Google Docs, Sheets and Drive | Sheets inside; Docs and Drive connected, reads and takes action | Docs and Sheets inside, as an early version; Drive connected, reads and takes action | Inside, from the Business Standard edition | Drive connected, reads only |
| Outlook | Connected, reads and takes action | Inside, as an early version; also connected, reads and takes action | No | Inside |
| Word, Excel and PowerPoint | Inside | Inside | No | Inside |
| Teams, SharePoint and OneDrive | Connected, reads and takes action | Connected, reads and takes action | No | Inside |
| Custom assistants | GPTs and Projects | Projects | Gems, shared like a Google Doc, on every edition | Agent Builder |
| Shared instructions and automations | Plugins (opens in a new tab) your team creates and shares | Claude Skills (opens in a new tab), which work without your admin switching them on and can be shared with colleagues or the whole firm | Workspace Studio (opens in a new tab) automations, on every edition | Copilot custom skills, as an early version |
Inside Microsoft's apps, Copilot answers from your team's email and files (opens in a new tab), and Gemini does the same inside Google's. Each person gets answers only from what they could already open (opens in a new tab). Both can also take notes in your video calls (opens in a new tab), on Teams or Google Meet.
Claude Team and ChatGPT Business work with Google's and Microsoft's apps and many others: on 15 November, Anthropic listed 1,128 apps Claude can connect to. If your team works in Gmail and Excel, Claude Team can work inside Excel (opens in a new tab) and read Gmail. ChatGPT Business can answer from what your team keeps in Slack and Notion (opens in a new tab).
Your team can also bring either assistant into Slack, where people mention it in a conversation and it replies there (OpenAI (opens in a new tab), Anthropic (opens in a new tab)). Claude's Slack assistant is still an early version. You pay for its work in shared Slack conversations as you go, on top of what you pay for seats.
When someone has the assistant checking the wording of quotes the way they want, they can save their instructions so colleagues run the same check. On Claude Team, for example, they save them as a Claude Skill and share it with the whole firm.
What each plan costs
If your team uses Google Workspace, you already pay for Gemini. Copilot Business, ChatGPT Business and Claude Team all cost extra.
| Plan | Price per person a month | What you need first |
|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT Business (opens in a new tab) | US$25, or US$20 paid yearly | At least two people on the plan |
| Claude Team (opens in a new tab) | US$25, or US$20 paid yearly | At least two people on the plan |
| Gemini in Google Workspace | Comes with Google Workspace. See Google's prices (opens in a new tab) | A Google Workspace business edition |
| Microsoft Copilot Business (opens in a new tab) | US$21 paid yearly, on top of Microsoft 365 | A Microsoft 365 business subscription (opens in a new tab), such as Business Basic, at US$7 paid yearly |
I checked these prices on 15 November 2026, so check the vendor's page on the day you buy. ChatGPT Business was called ChatGPT Team (opens in a new tab) until August 2025.
Run the month-long trial on monthly billing, which comes to US$50 a month for two people on ChatGPT Business or Claude Team. Once you've chosen, switch to yearly billing and pay US$20 a person a month. Copilot Business comes with a yearly commitment (opens in a new tab), even on monthly billing, so buy it only for the two or three people who'll run the test. Your admin then gives each of them a seat in the Microsoft 365 admin center.
If some of your team pay for ChatGPT Plus themselves, use my comparison of ChatGPT Business and Plus to work out what moving them over costs, and agree which of their chats belong to the firm.
Answering the phone with AI
Customers who phone instead of writing need a different kind of tool, sold separately from the four plans. Goodcall (opens in a new tab), for example, answers calls with an AI voice and books appointments. Smith.ai (opens in a new tab) pairs an AI receptionist with live agents, and Ruby (opens in a new tab) uses human receptionists.
Before you choose one, count the calls your team misses in a normal week, and note when they come in. If callers often need someone to decide on a price or an urgent job, pick a service that passes the call to a person. Then try it on those calls, and check every booking it makes in the first week.
Who controls access, and what happens to your information
Make one person the plan's admin: they add people, remove them and keep an eye on the bill. On Gemini or Copilot Business, that person works in the Google Admin console (opens in a new tab) or the Microsoft 365 admin center, where you already manage your team's email accounts.
You can leave training out of the choice, because each vendor says it doesn't train its models on your firm's work by default:
- OpenAI (opens in a new tab), for ChatGPT Business
- Anthropic (opens in a new tab), for Claude Team
- Google (opens in a new tab), for Gemini
- Microsoft (opens in a new tab), for Copilot Business
If you need to decide how long chats are kept, your admin can keep Gemini chats anywhere from 90 days to indefinitely (opens in a new tab), and set how long Copilot Business keeps them (opens in a new tab) in Microsoft 365. On ChatGPT and Claude, you need their Enterprise plans for that (OpenAI (opens in a new tab), Anthropic (opens in a new tab)).
When someone leaves, remove them on their last day. They lose access straight away on ChatGPT Business (opens in a new tab) and Claude Team (opens in a new tab), and the rest of the team can't open their private chats. So ask people to keep the firm's work in shared Projects, which stay with the firm on both plans (OpenAI (opens in a new tab), Anthropic (opens in a new tab)).
On both plans, you keep paying for the leaver's seat after you remove them (OpenAI (opens in a new tab), Anthropic (opens in a new tab)), so take it off the bill or give it to the next hire.
In Google Workspace, transfer the person's Drive files and Gmail before you delete their account, because Google deletes anything that isn't transferred (opens in a new tab). Your admin can restore a deleted account within 20 days.
Go through my six checks for client data too, to find out where each vendor stores your information.
Choosing the plan for your firm
- Pick two assistants to try, using the scores and what your team already pays for.
- Test both for a month on the task your team repeats most, with the people who do it.
- Check how the better one reaches your apps, and choose who'll be its admin.
- Move to yearly billing for the people who'll use it.
You pay for every seat each month, whether or not the person in it saves any time. In an AI Adoption Review, I map up to three of your team's workflows, check the AI tools you already pay for, and recommend which plan to buy for each workflow, or whether to leave it alone. I don't resell any of the four plans or take a fee from their vendors.
You get a business case for each recommendation, and a one-page rule set for which information goes into which tool. I charge a fixed fee for the review, and if it finds no workflow where AI pays off, you don't pay. It starts with a free 30-minute call about your team's work, and I quote the fee once we've agreed what the review covers.
To see which area to work on first, take the free AI readiness self-check.
